Suggestions for a good CD transport?

Mike

Audioshark
Staff member
Joined
Apr 2, 2013
Messages
30,482
Location
Sarasota, FL
Any suggestions for a good CD transport? I would love one that did SACD too, but I'm not aware of any non-proprietary interfaces to allow SACD.

I have my eye on the NAIM CDX-2 as one option.

Any other suggestions?
 
Marantz make some very nice spinners. If you want SACD you will be using the internal DAC built in the player and probably running digital outs to your DAC for Redbook CDs. The only way to legitimately run an SACD disks out of the spinner and be decoding with an external DAC is those that use proprietary connectors such as Esoteric and McIntosh which require you to use their players AND DACs. These are costly machines.

I run a Marantz SA8005 ($1200) which is a music only spinner. The SACD connect through analog outputs to the pre-amplifier while for Redbook CDs I use Coax digital outputs to my DAC.

But Mike, I assume you already know this :)....
 
Mike I have always felt that the Naim players are very high quality transports. No mechanical tray and read very accurately from my experience.
 
Marantz have a new flagship player arriving any day now. The hype is starting to build about it!
 
Probably the SA-10. Looks like a great machine that can up-sampling everything to quad-DSD. At $7000 a bit out of my price range :)....
 
Great suggestions. I guess none output SACD?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Great suggestions. I guess none output SACD?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Not in digital as far as I understand. That is against Sony's rules. Would love to have my SACDs go through the DAC3, but :(.... I am sure they would sound even better than using the Marantz DAC in my SA8005. It sounds like the SA10 has top notch DAC capabilities, but I have not been able to tell which DAC is being used. Would be something special if it was using the new ESS chips.... 9028 PRO or 9038 PRO. They are amazing!
 
Not in digital as far as I understand. That is against Sony's rules. Would love to have my SACDs go through the DAC3, but :(.... I am sure they would sound even better than using the Marantz DAC in my SA8005. It sounds like the SA10 has top notch DAC capabilities, but I have not been able to tell which DAC is being used. Would be something special if it was using the new ESS chips.... 9028 PRO or 9038 PRO. They are amazing!

A few more details. http://www.marantz.co.uk/uk/Product...tid=hifi&subcatid=sacdcdplayer&productid=sa10
 
Accuphase and Esoteric; both output DSD to their DACs.

As does McIntosh. However they all use proprietary cabling and do not export the DSD signal. They will all only accommodate their own player/DACs. Very expensive for many people.

Most spinners that output HDMI convert the signal to PCM. Being able to record the HDMI is very rare.
 
If you're after a great sounding transport, I'd look for a 2nd hand Reimyo CDP-777 in excellent nick. The Reimyo had the Victor/JVC XL-Z900 transport which is probably the best off the shelf transport mech ever made (though RBCD only), as well as the excellent K2 Extended processor. But the upshot is you can pick them up now for a fraction of the cost of a top range Accuphase, Soulution or CH Precision transport. That player would be awesome connected to something like a Vimak DS-1800 Mk2 dac or Dan Wright's Modwright Elyse dac.
 
Were you aware that until a few years ago, there were only a handful of companies making high end SACD/CD transports? Sony, Esoteric, and another company whose name I forget. All high end transports were sourced from them. These days, there is only Esoteric, and Esoteric has stopped third party sales of transports. This is why companies like Playback Designs have stopped offering SACD players and have turned into a DAC company - because their transport supply has dried up. DCS has a stock of Esoteric transports, but they only move a handful of their high end Vivaldi transports anyway. As for MSB, they use a modified Oppo and are quite open about this.

In short - all transports right now, with the exception of Esoteric, are mass market low end transports. If you want a superb transport, look for a secondhand transport based on the Sony ES mechanism, or a transport based on Esoteric (e.g. Playback Designs, DCS), or get a new Esoteric.

Note that I am only talking about the disc spinning mechanism and laser assembly itself. The bit that slides in and out might make the transport look proprietary, but the underlying mechanism/laser is still a mass market transport. Neither am I referring to the electronics that looks at the data after it is read. Some, like the Memory Player (not sure if it's still around) reads until it is perfect, buffers it in memory, reclocks it, and sends it. I believe the PS Audio Perfectwave transport uses a low end disc spinning mechanism (low end compared to Esoteric), but it is the electronics that make it special.
 
Back
Top