Neil Young's most beautiful song ?

[A.S.]

Is ''Harvest Moon'' Neil Young's most beautiful composition?
Or.....?

[Cory Cooper]

I think Helpless is...



C

[Mike]

[Myles B. Astor]

It's a real tough choice but I just love the lyrics and imagery conjured up in the song.

Especially:

"Somewhere on a desert highway
She rides a Harley Davidson
Her long blond hair flyin' in the wind
She's been runnin' half her life
The chrome and steel she rides
Collidin' with the very air she breathes
The air she breathes"

[Petro85]

Is ''Harvest Moon'' Neil Young's most beautiful composition?
Or.....?

haha!!!! great song, first i ever learned on a guitar.

[BruceLet]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=etedzSdD_XI&feature=kp

[NorthStar]

___________________________

[tunes]

It's a real tough choice but I just love the lyrics and imagery conjured up in the song.

Especially:

"Somewhere on a desert highway
She rides a Harley Davidson
Her long blond hair flyin' in the wind
She's been runnin' half her life
The chrome and steel she rides
Collidin' with the very air she breathes
The air she breathes"

Love this one too! And i've got it on tape Myles
The downside is the guy i got it from dubbed from a cd
Chris

[Shadowfax]

I'm gonna go against the grain and vote for Cortez the Killer, although content is not all that cheery.

[Myles B. Astor]

I thought it was one choice.

[NorthStar]

I thought it was one choice.

We don't always have to abide by the laws. ...If we did life would be extremely boring. ...No?
... "Rockin' in the Free World"

[Myles B. Astor]

I'll take an order of boring in this case.

[NorthStar]

Suit yourself.

* Regarding Neil :: Is High-Resolution Audio Irrelevant?

[MusicDirector]

I'll do more than one then. All very nice selections so far. I'll add these:

[A.S.]

I thought it was one choice.

If you can not choose,for me, no problem. Keep ém coming!

[A.S.]

Is ''Harvest Moon'' Neil Young's most beautiful composition?
Or.....?

How many votes for Harvest Moon?

[Asamel]

"It's all one song" - N. Young

[MusicDirector]

Forgot this one: "I Am A Child".

[Bobvin]

Harvest Moon... many years back I was paddling with some friends up in eastern British Columbia, in the Bowron Lakes wilderness. Its a great circuit, 75 miles, 50 miles deep in wilderness at the turn. You end up where you started. Awesome weather for the first several days... late September. Perfect, no wind, lakes like glass. We leap-frogged another group who were in canoes. My friends were in canoes, I was in my sea kayak. On the fourth morning, just as we were getting into our boats, we see the other group enter the small lake we were about to leave. As we were getting into our boats the wind came up, from about 3 knots to 45 knots in span of a minute or two. The other group, in the canoes, were in the middle of the lake, no life jackets, gear not secured to the boats. One canoe capsized, the other was blown to the far shore.

The lake is fed by glacial runoff, so very cold water. Wind too strong to effect a rescue, so we watched until one guy went under. Finally wind died down a little and I got in my sea kayak and pulled the other fellow to shore. I've never paddled so hard or prayed as hard as I did for the 20 minutes it took to drag him ashore, draped over my paddle float. We had someone paddle down the river to a ranger radio station. They sent in a helicopter to take the survivor out. They looked for the body for a few days, but didn't find it until the next spring. The ombudsman said "when winter comes to the Caribou [mountains], it comes hard." First fatality on that circuit in 20 years.

That experience really tore me up. On the way home I had one CD in my truck, Harvest Moon. I played the song over and over, cried my eyes out over and over. The fellow who drowned had an 8 yr old daughter, and lost her mom to cancer just the year before. Every time I hear that song it brings tears to my eyes.

[bzr]

Bob, tragic story. I often wonder at the little curves life throws at people.

[Mike]

Bob, what a horrific event. So sad.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Toobs]

[I]Harvest Moon is certainly a great song, as all of his songs are. To single out one as being his best is impossible to do. My personal favorite is Old Man.

If anyone gets a chance to watch After the Gold Rush live at the Ryman Auditorium do not miss itI]

[Asamel]

At this moment in time I'm really liking the acoustic intro to "Drifting Back". The song morphs into an electric free for all that goes about 30 minutes.

[Garth]

Neil Young and beautiful in the same sentence . Good thing your talking about his music

[Glareskin]

Definitely this 'Old Man' version.


The high res BluRay Audio version from The Archives Vol. 1 sounds FANTASTIC!!! I have got a rip as high res FLAC on my NAS and it is amazing.

[Alpinist]

After the Gold Rush - Takes me back to when I was a teenager and was hanging out with my best buddy. Lost him to a drunk driver 25 years ago this coming November.

Ken

[A.S.]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=etedzSdD_XI&feature=kp

very very pretty! thx for posting

[BruceLet]

"Love in Mind" from Live at Massey Hall….Best sounding Neil Young recording of all time. Desert island vinyl.